On November 3, 1964, Alabama's voters voted for ten at-large electors. Two electoral slates ran.
The (unpledged) Democratic candidates:
The Republican candidates:
The county returns (for Place 1) are as follows:
| Genier (Republican) | Allen (Democratic) | |
| Autauga | 2968 | 490 |
| Baldwin | 10880 | 2530 |
| Barbour | 3891 | 978 |
| Bibb | 2609 | 503 |
| Blount | 4414 | 2427 |
| Bullock | 1512 | 1114 |
| Butler | 4006 | 973 |
| Calhoun | 10575 | 6210 |
| Chambers | 4622 | 2557 |
| Cherokee | 1882 | 1916 |
| Chilton | 5176 | 1645 |
| Choctaw | 2497 | 413 |
| Clarke | 4463 | 924 |
| Clay | 2805 | 1199 |
| Cleburne | 2151 | 672 |
| Coffee | 4831 | 1213 |
| Colbert | 5271 | 5573 |
| Conecuh | 2784 | 639 |
| Coosa | 1970 | 740 |
| Covington | 7548 | 1621 |
| Crenshaw | 3006 | 816 |
| Cullman | 7123 | 5110 |
| Dale | 4986 | 963 |
| Dallas | 5883 | 719 |
| DeKalb | 6735 | 4948 |
| Elmore | 6333 | 1233 |
| Escambia | 5625 | 1928 |
| Etowah | 12843 | 8939 |
| Fayette | 3,207 | 1287 |
| Franklin | 4021 | 3110 |
| Geneva | 4491 | 1074 |
| Greene | 1123 | 587 |
| Hale | 1900 | 548 |
| Henry | 2897 | 589 |
| Houston | 10527 | 1421 |
| Jackson | 2711 | 3145 |
| Jefferson | 99803 | 38082 |
| Lamar | 2,726 | 1,041 |
| Lauderdale | 5963 | 6593 |
| Lawrence | 1809 | 1808 |
| Lee | 5899 | 1602 |
| Limestone | 2370 | 3027 |
| Lowndes | 1551 | 310 |
| Macon | 1833 | 2973 |
| Madison | 14288 | 13217 |
| Marengo | 3,659 | 789 |
| Marion | 4043 | 1747 |
| Marshall | 5694 | 4428 |
| Mobile | 49399 | 20488 |
| Monroe | 3,859 | 886 |
| Montgomery | 22856 | 7482 |
| Morgan | 6951 | 5368 |
| Perry | 2036 | 520 |
| Pickens | 3310 | 746 |
| Pike | 4366 | 803 |
| Randolph | 3112 | 1864 |
| Russell | 4872 | 1537 |
| Shelby | 6023 | 1943 |
| St. Clair | 4811 | 1989 |
| Sumter | 1653 | 405 |
| Talladega | 8872 | 3712 |
| Tallapoosa | 5518 | 1733 |
| Tuscaloosa | 13157 | 6036 |
| Walker | 8541 | 6110 |
| Washington | 2791 | 1191 |
| Wilcox | 1783 | 157 |
| Winston | 3438 | 1391 |
| Total | 477,252 (69.37%) | 210,732 (30.63%) |
The Republican slate was duly elected, and voted for Goldwater and Miller on December 14.