On November 6, 1860, Alabama's voters voted for nine at-large electors. Three electoral slates ran.
The Breckinridge candidates:[src]
The alternate Breckinridge candidates:
The Douglas candidates:[src]
The alternate Douglas candidates:
The Constitutional Union candidates:[src]
The alternate Constitutional Union candidates:
The county returns are as follows:
| Breckinridge | Const. Unionists | Douglas | |
| Autauga | 611 | 256 | 394 |
| Baldwin | 129 | 248 | 81 |
| Barbour | 1715 | 645 | 9 |
| Bibb | 613 | 582 | 156 |
| Blount | 546 | 51 | 443 |
| Butler | 918 | 1079 | 111 |
| Calhoun | 2347 | 364 | 54 |
| Chambers | 1017 | 919 | 157 |
| Cherokee | 1706 | 527 | 223 |
| Choctaw | 542 | 472 | 158 |
| Clarke | 952 | 255 | 77 |
| Coffee | 878 | 394 | 2 |
| Conecuh | 348 | 338 | 205 |
| Coosa | 930 | 706 | 844 |
| Covington | 404 | 416 | 12 |
| Dale | 1280 | 277 | 5 |
| Dallas | 833 | 620 | 339 |
| DeKalb | 849 | 204 | 202 |
| Fayette | 1299 | 359 | 37 |
| Franklin | 902 | 715 | 460 |
| Greene | 696 | 765 | 157 |
| Henry | 1109 | 317 | |
| Jackson | 1760 | 130 | 565 |
| Jefferson | 831 | 245 | 78 |
| Lauderdale | 706 | 444 | 790 |
| Lawrence | 370 | 525 | 576 |
| Limestone | 522 | 368 | 325 |
| Lowndes | 1007 | 592 | 57 |
| Macon | 1184 | 1210 | 46 |
| Madison | 591 | 400 | 1300 |
| Marengo | 838 | 512 | 68 |
| Marion | 986 | 197 | 62 |
| Marshall | 441 | 165 | 763 |
| Mobile | 1541 | 1629 | 1823 |
| Monroe | 530 | 447 | 222 |
| Montgomery | 1555 | 1034 | 133 |
| Morgan | 549 | 144 | 545 |
| Perry | 982 | 793 | 99 |
| Pickens | 1211 | 619 | 16 |
| Pike | 1581 | 1227 | 84 |
| Randolph | 1734 | 537 | 343 |
| Russell | 993 | 854 | 53 |
| Shelby | 853 | 570 | 186 |
| St. Clair | 963 | 174 | 240 |
| Sumter | 682 | 473 | 136 |
| Talladega | 1307 | 1091 | 74 |
| Tallapoosa | 1451 | 1270 | 298 |
| Tuscaloosa | 1219 | 1023 | 23 |
| Walker | 446 | 103 | 303 |
| Washington | 176 | 155 | 24 |
| Wilcox | 833 | 355 | 113 |
| Winston | 203 | 40 | 147 |
| Total | 48,669 (54.00%) | 27,835 (30.89%) | 13,618 (15.11%) |
The Breckinridge slate was duly elected, and voted for Breckinridge and Lane on December 5.